People love Rock Of Ages, Cleft For Me, with good reason. Together, the text (written by Augustus M. Toplady) and the most often-used melody (entitled “Toplady,” written by Thomas Hastings) make a fitting hymn for obeying God’s command:
Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly, teaching and admonishing one another in all wisdom, singing psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, with thankfulness in your hearts to God. — Colossians 3:16 (ESV)
Let’s examine it to see what we can learn as songwriters, worship leaders, and disciples of Jesus.
Like many old hymns, the text has survived (and sometimes benefitted from) lyrical revision at the hands of individual poets and hymnal committees. I will use the version my church (Sojourn) sings, because I feel it is the best. It’s a popular version, but I will point out some equally popular textual variants. You can see the lyrics and chords to Sojourn’s version here, and listen to it as sung (and arranged) by my friend Brooks Ritter:
The Basics: Hymn Meter and Subject Matter:
Church On The Rock in Cracow, Poland
“Rock of Ages” is a 77.77.77 meter hymn. As I discussed here, hymns with 7-syllable lines are typically trochaic, meaning the vocal emphasis falls on the odd syllables when sung or spoken. These 7-syllable trochaic lines are abrupt, starting with a bang, and are thus appropriate for conveying strong emotions, such as excitement, remorse, love and repentance. “HELP me!” is a trochaic cry.
So Toplady has chosen a good hymn meter, given that his subject matter is plaintive and pleading: “Jesus, let me hide in you.” Let’s break down the main thought of each verse:
- Save and cleanse me
- I can’t do it on my own
- I can’t even help, or offer anything. I bring nothing to the table.
- This will end badly for me if you don’t intercede. I’m guilty as can be.
Notice the natural progression of thought in these verses. A common problem among songwriters is that they write verses in which each verse beyond the first merely repeats the information or story line of the first, rather than shed new light or advance the plot. Not so with “Rock Of Ages.”
As for the melody, Hasting’s tune evokes these lyrics well. And if I can put in a word for a friend, I think Brooks’ chord structure improves upon it by tying the melody even closer to the poetry.
Verse By Verse:
Rock of Ages, cleft for me,
Let me hide myself in Thee:
Let the water and the blood,
From thy wounded side which flowed,
Be of sin the double cure;
Save from wrath and make me pure.
The rhyme scheme for these six lines (and the rest of the hymn) is AABBCC, meaning that each couplet (unit of two back-to-back lines) rhymes. Notice how strong action verbs propel the story: cleft, hide, save, make. Learn from Toplady; use strong verbs.
We also get the immediate, colorful metaphor “Rock of ages.” Rock is a common biblical metaphor for God, used over 20 times this way in the book of Psalms alone. But Toplady’s use of this metaphor stems from an earlier source: Moses, who had requested to see God’s “glory.”
God explained that his glory was too great for frail, fallen flesh to see. Moses would die at the sight of it. So God says:
and while my glory passes by I will put you in a cleft of the rock, and I will cover you with my hand until I have passed by. — Exodus: 33:22 ESV Continue reading →